Memory-based font not rendering properly on Windows

[george-spitfire]

Hi,

I am seeing an issue with a memory-based font I’m using in that it renders correctly on Mac but not Windows for identical code. I’ve made a simple app to show the issue, the only lines I’ve added on top of the basic GUI app template are in paint():

void MainContentComponent::paint (Graphics& g)
{
    g.fillAll (Colour (0xff001F36));

    auto myFont = Font (Typeface::createSystemTypefaceFor (BinaryData::News_Gothic_Extra_Condensed_Bold_otf,
                                                           BinaryData::News_Gothic_Extra_Condensed_Bold_otfSize));

    myFont.setHeight (25);
    g.setFont (myFont);
    g.setColour (Colours::white);
    g.drawSingleLineText ("News Gothic Extra Condensed Bold", 20, 30);

}

This gives the following results:

Mac – font displaying correctly

Windows – font not displaying correctly

This is using a .otf file for the font, if I convert to a .ttf the issue goes away and both platforms display the font correctly.

Does anyone know what the issue is here?

Thanks,

George

(Sorry, I can’t add a .zip or .otf, below is a download link for the .otf I’m using. If anyone wants a copy of the app for debugging just let me know. http://fontsgeek.com/fonts/News-Gothic-Extra-Condensed-Bold)

[jules]

This rings a bell - IIRC there was just some mysterious problem that stopped Windows from loading OTFs correctly when they’re done as in-memory fonts. Not sure whether a fix is even possible for it, I think just sticking to TTFs might be the answer

[lcapozzi]

something similar also happens with TTF, afaik. I’ve never been able to match how the fonts are rendered (using the same cross platform font file) between Mac and PC.

[otristan]

@george-spitfire Did you find a solution to this ?
We are seeing similar issue even with TTF if user has installed some custom font on his system.

Thanks !

[masshacker]

We’ve been experiencing this too, since about two years.
Memory based TTF.

[BastienC]

Windows10 issue with system custom fonts overrides in Graphics::drawText (+workaround)

I noticed that when a custom font is installed in windows os, the call to Graphics::drawText is not using the font set with setFont but overrides it with the installed custom font from windows. Steps to reproduce: 1/ Search on google the font “Google Font: EB Garamond” 2/ Download and Install them 3/ Graphics::drawText does not work properly anymore Workaround (sort of) : The workaround for this is to replace the g.drawText() by a custom method creating a textLayout, I place it is my main …

[masshacker]

I found a fix for my use case. I don’t know if this is useful, anyway here it goes:
In my case the problem was happening for some fonts that have particular styles (e.g. Bold, Italic).
This is what I was doing, in pseudo code:

auto myFont(Typeface::createSystemTypefaceFor(ItalicFontName, ItalicFontSize));
font.setStyleFlags(Font::italic);

Calling setStyleFlags destroyed the contained typeface.
And this seems to be the culprit.
Taking a look into the setStyleFlags implementation I see

font->typeface = nullptr;

I don’t know why this is happening on Windows only.
Maybe @ed95 could take a look at this?
You can try with the DSEG14Classic-Italic.ttf font contained in the package available at https://www.keshikan.net/fonts-e.html