New forum opinion

looks like something is messing up the API page CSS

That happened because of a ā€œfalse startā€ with the new forum yesterday night, mentioned by jules here: Welcome to the new forum and JUCE 4.2

Maybe two themes could be provided and each user may choose which one to use?

Don’t think it supports that AFAIK

Ah sorry, I confused that with the ā€œLanguageā€ setting while quickly updating my profile details.
I saw a combo and automatically thought ā€œcool, multiple themesā€. My fault!

My desire for a dark theme would be if the site could support multiple themes, rather than radically changing the design for everyone. The white doesn’t bother me too much since at night I use f.lux to prevent eyestrain from bright colors.

Sadly, I think it’s hard to please everyone because we’re a bunch of programmers who get stuck in our ways and complain either way. Think like when Facebook was changing the user home page every so often and the whole world would complain for a month and then accept it. We see the flaws with the old things and complain about how we think they could be done better, then when they change based on our feedback we see the smallest details that are wrong (in a still changing platform) and continue complaining.

Like I said, I think overall this new forum is a massive upgrade to the early-2000’s look of the old one.

2 Likes

One thing I would definitely recommend is that dates include the year.

I searched for a post and did not know what year it was from.

A jump list does not solve the problem of navigating. Maybe making it full width is what I am missing. Heck I have a high res monitor and the forum is only using half the screen

Am I missing something?

2 Likes

I think that the year is not mentioned when the post is in the current year. For older posts, you get Month and 'year, for example Dec '13 (but, I agree, that’s easily misunderstood for 13th December rather than December 2013)

Thanks, that explains the year confusion although I wish it were obvious.

The font sucks :slight_smile: Too thin and big?

1 Like

Better in Helvetica, or Open Sans?? e.g.

The good news is that image paste is GREAT :slight_smile:

3 Likes

Yeah, the font seems to be top of the ā€œmoan listā€! We hear you…

Probably looks great on the right retina macbook :wink: But on my old cinema display it’s super-fuzz and thin with a lot of the verticals being antialiased into a blur! Not sure whether the screenshot will do the effect justice, but as it’s easy now to paste one in:

1 Like

Actually I like it the way it is, font and color scheme. Some things to get used to, but I trust in our abilities…
Just missing the tags, eventually instead of the categories. Doesn’t need to be creatable by everyone, it could start a hash-tag-mania, but tags like ā€œMultiBusā€, or ā€œOSCā€ or ā€œMIDI eventsā€ would help to sort things faster…

Nice work as usual! My congratulations to all Juce/Roli people.
Of course, something flaws has to be pruned, but happy to belong to this community!

Gabriel

Ok my 2 cents:

  • overall more ā€œmodernā€, but do we care ?
  • Don’t really care about the font, but Bazrush’s remarks (among others) seem reasonable
  • I hate the … in the dropdown menus, there should be enough room to list the complete submenu titles. That would be my main criticism
  • I will answer my own post (this one) when I use this more and find other relevant issues
1 Like

I really wish you guys had gone with ProBoards or SimpleMachineForums instead of whatever you guys are using now… This new forum interface is probably gonna make me use the forum even less because it’s harder to find anything. At least turn on a global navigation header that isn’t hidden behind some dropdown hamburger thing.

Also, all of our private messages were not imported when you changed forum software.

I like the new forum including the theme, the font is ok, it does look nice on hi-res displays, but for big chunks of text there indeed are more readable and space-efficient (less wide) fonts including the ones that have been mentionned above. Thanks for the bright background. If someone really dislikes the font/bg, then there’s always the option of override the css file in your own browser.

I would really appreciate a dark theme… I can’t look at this bright theme for more than a minute or two without getting a headache.

If you dislike bright backgrounds in general, try the ā€œCare your Eyesā€ addon for chrome. It allows dark bgs on any webpage and works nicely with the juce forum.